Thursday, March 03, 2011

Lessons from Hackney

Last night Hackney Council passed a budget with £44 million of cuts, amidst protests from anti-cuts campaigners. Having looked at their budget, I think councillors have done very well in extremely difficult situation - unlike in many other councils, no youth facilities will be closed, no libraries shut, no reduction to key services like recycling or street cleansing, no restrictions on care to be provided to our oldest and most vulnerable of residents, and the council is maintaining services such as support for victims of domestic violence and youth crime intervention work which the national government had cut funding for.

There is an irony in watching protesters who say all political parties are just the same with one breath, while with the next protesting against the Tory/Lib Dem decision to end Labour's policy of giving more money to the most deprived areas.

Hackney councillors will face an even harder job next year, with a further £26 million in cuts needing to be made. I think it is worth revisiting an article I wrote in 2009, in response to Hackney's decision to freeze their council tax.

There are good reasons for trying to keep council tax low - particularly in poor areas where it was historically amongst the highest in the country. But it is one of the few ways that local councils can raise money, as the following example shows:

If Hackney Council had decided in 2006, instead of freezing their council tax, to raise it by 1% per year, then they would have raised roughly £900,000 per year, at an extra cost to the average household of £10 per year (more for people in higher value properties, less for people in lower value properties, and nothing for people eligible for council tax benefit).

Over four years, this would mean that the average household would be paying an extra £50 per year, and the council would have an extra £3.65 million to spend on local services. This year and next year, it would also have received an extra £90,000 from central government in council tax freeze grant.

If, instead, councillors had raised council tax by 2% per year, then the average household would be £2 per week worse off (more for wealthier households, nothing for the poorest households), and the council would have approximately £7.5 million in extra revenue, including council tax from residents, extra council tax benefit and council tax freeze grant.

*

Now, obviously, an extra £3.5-£7 million in revenue wouldn't prevent all the cuts, and higher council tax would make life even tougher for many people, particularly lower paid workers and pensioners who are just above the threshold for receiving benefits. But, crudely, the overall impact of small annual increases in council tax would be that young professionals in the trendy bits of the borough would now be paying more taxes to provide services for people with long term illnesses to receive social care, young people to be able to go to enjoyable and safe activities on the estates, and victims of domestic violence to get support when they need it.

Labour councils are still boasting about having taken the "tough decision" to freeze the council tax. I think most councillors are doing their best now in desperately tough times, but a really tough and correct decision would have been to raise council tax while Labour was in power, in order to help protect our communities when this bunch of sub-Thatcherite extremists took over.

11 Comments:

At 2:38 pm , Anonymous sewa mobil said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.

 
At 6:28 pm , Blogger Laban said...

OK, how are they doing it? Where are the cuts landing?

(Impressed btw. Some Labour councils seem to be cutting front line staff with a 'look what you made us do' rhetoric.)

 
At 9:18 am , Anonymous Cooper said...

I am very interested in this kind of information. Thank you for sharing your ideas and knowledge.

 
At 1:12 pm , Blogger Rory said...

Very interesting, the only way to win in 2015 is to learn from these elections.

I'm a 16 year old Labour activist and have just set up a new blog, It would be great if you could have a look and if you added to to your bloggroll I'd be really grateful:
http://a-week-is-a-long-time-in-politics.blogspot.com/

 
At 1:17 pm , Anonymous paul said...

I agree with the article, the councillors have done a lot in tough conditions.

 
At 10:36 am , Blogger rahul said...

Thanks for great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you



Payment Protection Claims

 
At 4:50 pm , Blogger Robert said...

what are doing how are they cutting tell us so i can tell my council who is cutting everything except their bloated wages.

 
At 1:53 pm , Anonymous Bloggingbooks said...

Dear don-paskini blog author,

I work for Bloggingbooks publishing house (bloggingbooks.net), which is the new publishing brand of SVH publishing house.

We are looking forward to extend our publishing programme, and we are therefore searching intensively for interesting and well presented blogs that may be suitable for publishing.

Would you be interested too in publishing your blog posts? I look forward to a positive reply from you.

Should you have any questions, I would be pleased to answer your queries by e-mail. You may also get more information about Bloggingbooks concept, by visiting our website.

contact email: m [dot] gorbulea [at] bloggingbooks [dot] de

 
At 12:14 am , Anonymous sewa mobil said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.

 
At 1:42 pm , Anonymous Bloggingbooks said...

Dear don-paskini blog author,

I work for Bloggingbooks publishing house, which is the new publishing brand of SVH publishing house.

We are looking forward to extend our publishing programme, and we are therefore searching intensively for interesting and well presented blogs that may be suitable for publishing.

Would you be interested too in publishing your blog posts? I look forward to a positive reply from you.

Should you have any questions, I would be pleased to answer your queries by e-mail. You may also get more information about Bloggingbooks concept, by visiting our website.

contact email: m [dot] gorbulea [at] bloggingbooks [dot] de

 
At 5:36 am , Anonymous DarutNews.com said...

hello brother

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home