Monday, March 21, 2016

Be useful, be kind: the future welfare state

It would take a heart of stone not to enjoy Iain Duncan Smith's resignation and the ongoing collision between the promises that the Tories made at the last election and reality.

However, none of this makes it any easier for those of us who would like to see more decent and humane ŵelfare policy.  Recent research by Britain Thinks for the Labour Party summarised what swing voters think about welfare policy.  Their hope is that the government will reward people who contribute and 'sort out the scroungers'.  Anyone who thinks these attitudes are restricted to swing voters should have a look at this research by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

How to respond to this?

Firstly, even before their budget fell apart, we know that the Tories won't achieve this.  Their welfare reforms have created a system in which people experiencing tough times are more and more likely to be caught out and punished by arbitrary rules, while people who just want to play the system continue to get what they want.

Secondly, the approach of telling voters that they are wrong to be concerned about benefit fraud and scroungers and trying to educate them to think differently isn't working.

Thirdly, the best ideas come from the people who use ŵelfare services, rather than think tanks and the political elite. Compare and contrast policy disasters such such as the Work Capability Assessment and Universal Credit, to the living wage or the ideas of the Spartacus Network.

So let's start by assuming that when people say that they want a system to reward contributors and sort out scroungers, that our goal should be to come up with ideas to make that happen rather than telling them why they are wrong.  This will require different policies from those of the government, and we should listen to people at the grassroots as they will have the best ideas.

Swing voters dislike a system which seems to be all about what people can take, and where there seems to be no relationship between what people do for others and what they receive.  Similarly, those who need support are frustrated by a system which often seems to put barriers in the way who want to help others, with arbitrary assessments and inadequate help which isn't suited to their needs. To get support, you need to understand how to work the rules to show what you can't do and make sure that your problemsare seen as sufficiently serious.

I was recently reading All our Ŵelfare, Peter Beresford's excellent book on the welfare state.  He defines welfare as being about 'how we look after each other in society'.  He also makes a powerful and compelling case that rather than experts assessing what people need, people should be able - with advocacy and support - to identify what support they need to do the things that they want to do.  Rather than starting with what people can't do, this approach starts with what they can do.

So here's a suggestion.  What if welfare services in future started not with a diagnosis about whether people are eligible for support, but instead was organised around two questions:

What do you want to do to help other people?
What support do you need to be able to do this?

In other words, the welfare state becomes about what people can give, and enabling them to give more, not what they can take.  Rather than the toxic divide between "taxpayers" and "scroungers", this draws on the ideas and priorities of people who use services to respond to the swing voters.

This also recognises that paid employment is one way to contribute and help others, but that raising a family, volunteering to help others with the same health condition and many other activities are also ways of contributing to our general welfare.  That's something we've known for many years, but which some in the Labour Party with their tokenistic talk about different benefit levels for people depending on how long they have worked seem to have forgotten.  

It would also make the welfare system open to and useful for many more people - people who are self employed or running a small business and who want help to be able to develop their business, hire more people and so on, as just one example.  It would recognise that people with disabilities aren't passive victims, but that it is all of our responsibility to change society to help them to fulfil their potential.

This intentionally isn't a detailed shopping list of policies.  A system designed on these principles will keep some of the existing system and get rid of other bits, and involve people who provide and receive services in deciding what works and what needs changing.

It is easy to see how a system like this would do more to reward contributors.  That would, after all, be its starting point and main aim.  But how would it sort out the scroungers?

Firstly, it would be much tougher for people who are only interested in what they can take, or in taking benefits as a lifestyle choice.  At the moment, they just need to learn the rules and jump through the hoops.  It is much tougher to do this if the starting point is about what you can do for other people, rather than what you can take from the taxpayer.

But more than that, here's a real life example of what it might mean:

Down on Benefits Street in the north west of England, there lived a Hard to Reach Scrounger.  Every year, he received thousands of pounds in benefits from the taxpayer, and hundreds of thousands more indirectly in support from a whole range of different professionals for his various problems.  Every day, he would call 999 several times, and the police would have to come out and respond to whatever the drama of the day was.

So one day, the police tried a new approach.  Rather than waiting for him to call 999, they sent someone round and had a chat with him.  They found out more about his life, about his skills and about how he had had a breakdown which meant he had quit his job and got into the problems he was experiencing.  Then from this, they worked with the other professionals to put together the support he needed for his drink and drugs addictions.  Then they helped him to get a job.  

They needed someone with construction project management skills for the Jobs, Friends, Houses project they were running where people coming out of prison were hired to refurbish homes: learning new skills and doing something useful.  He used to be a project manager and had the skills they needed.  Now instead of being a scrounger, he is working hard and using his skills to help others.

There is no tick box or one size fits all solution to helping people to help each other.  Any system will need to be complicated and flexible because people's lives are complicated and what works for one person won't work for another.  But treating people with respect and supporting and challenging them to help others doesn't just reward contributors.  It also turns scroungers into contributors.

*

President Obama recently summed up his hopes for his children in four words: "be useful, be kind".  If that is good enough for the children of the President of the United States, it sounds like a good aim for the welfare state too.  A system which enables people to be useful and kind to each other, and which itself is useful and kind: surely this is a worthwhile alternative to the mess which Iain Duncan Smith has left behind.

16 Comments:

At 7:38 am , Blogger keerthisuresh said...


you need more publicize this so many people who know about it are rare for people to know this one.This is a great article for the people who want to come in freelancing.


SAP Training in Chennai

 
At 9:09 am , Blogger Rekhila Pk said...

Your blog is awesome..You have clearly explained ...Its very useful for me to know about new things..Keep on blogging..
SAP Training in Chennai

 
At 10:06 am , Blogger Rekhila Pk said...

Your blog is awesome..You have clearly explained ...Its very useful for me to know about new things..Keep on blogging..
SAP Training in Chennai

 
At 10:55 am , Blogger saki said...

thanks for shared wonderful information of giving best information.its more useful and more helpful. great doing keep sharing
Hadoop Training in Chennai

 
At 7:43 am , Anonymous Reeta said...

thks a lot:-)To know more seo training chennai


Great post....Thank you for posting the great content……I found it quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such blogs…
If you Want more seo course chennai

 
At 2:54 am , Blogger dong dong23 said...

ray bans
timberland boots
kobe 11
cheap oakley sunglasses
true religion
kate spade outlet
louis vuitton outlet
cheap jordans
kobe bryant shoes
michael kors outlet
kate spade
christian louboutin outlet
coach outlet
coach factory outlet
gucci outlet
jordan shoes
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors handbags
coach factory outlet
jordans for sale
michael kors outlet
air max 90
nike air max 90
oakley sunglasses
adidas shoes
nike roshe runs
nike air force
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton
coach outlet store online clearances
louis vuitton bags
mont blanc pens
coach factory outlet
toms outlet
nike air huarache
toms outlet
ralph lauren polo
pandora jewelry
20167.9wengdongdong

 
At 10:47 am , Anonymous Vikranth said...

This is really a great post. Thank you for taking time to provide us some of the useful and exclusive information with us. Keep on blogging!!

ROI Services in Chennai

 
At 8:58 am , Blogger Aasha said...

Really nice information you had posted. Its very informative and definitely it will be useful for many people

Digital Marketing For Small Business in Chennai

 
At 9:35 am , Blogger Suseela Susiee said...



All are saying the same thing repeatedly, but in your blog I had a chance to get some useful and unique information, I love your writing style very much, I would like to suggest your blog in my dude circle, so keep on updates.


Digital Marketing Company in Chennai

 
At 10:10 am , Anonymous Mala said...

Nice to see your blog post.. I really enjoyed by reading your blog post. Thanks a lot for sharing this with us.. Keep on sharing like this informative post.

Branding Services in Chennai

 
At 10:13 am , Blogger Suseela Susiee said...



All are saying the same thing repeatedly, but in your blog I had a chance to get some useful and unique information, I love your writing style very much, I would like to suggest your blog in my dude circle, so keep on updates.


Online Reputation Management

 
At 3:29 am , Blogger aaa kitty20101122 said...

yeezy shoes
nike roshe run
yeezy boost 350
michael kors outlet
michael kors uk
michael kors handbags
yeezy boost
chrome hearts online
asics running shoes
chrome hearts online

 
At 3:40 pm , Blogger Merlin Maarit said...


It is very helpful for me. Keep blogging like this.


Healthcare Analytics Company

Finance Analytics Company

Telecom Analytics Company

Retail Analytics Company

Analytics Company

US IT Staffing Agency

 
At 10:32 am , Blogger happy 123 said...

adidas yeezy
michael kors handbags
yeezy boost 350
pandora bracelet
air max 2016
kobe 9
adidas ultra boost
patriots jersey
jordan shoes
true religion jeans
20170626

 
At 10:46 am , Blogger Karthi Keyan said...

Its fantatic explaintion lot of information gather it...nice article....
seo company in Chennai

 
At 8:46 am , Blogger عبده العمراوى said...

شركة تنظيف مجالس بالدمام
شركة المثالية للتنظيف بالاحساء

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home